Author’s Note: What began as a mere dabbling into my family roots has become a robust investigation of my family history. Slowly the search has become centered on the lives, decisions and events of the Civil War era, 1850-1880, as they shaped the physical and mental landscape in which my grandparents and parents lived. Here I repost an essay from last summer, in which I first grapple with how those past lives reached out to touch my childhood, my mental landscape.
I am American by birth, Virginian by the grace of God.
And like many southern white children of the 1960’s I grew up in a culture that wore its defeat like a thick woolen cloak draped around one’s shoulders, adorned by the tales of our brave soldiers J.E.B. Stuart and Stonewall Jackson. To be Virginian was to represent your family and your state with honor, as demonstrated by that great leader Robert E. Lee. You may not believe in the cornerstone argument BUT you must honor your duty to the motherland and your family, and rise to their defense!
While the institution of slavery was mentioned, pro-slavery racism and its sibling Jim Crow segregation were not discussed. Ever so subtly children inherited their parents’ mistrust and loathing of all things Yankee, and even with a Yankee mother I could not escape this net.
I remember walking the hall of my high school, surrounded by my black and white friends, laughing and taunting the plain clothes police officer lurking in the dark corner–present to protect any little white child from unruly mobs. Discussing the latest desegregation violence in Boston, one of my gang cried,”Ain’t so easy, is it, Yankee Boy!” We all hated the hypocrisy of the Yank, whose finger pointed to the South as the crucible of all American sin and never at himself, ignoring the seeds of racism within his factories, cities, and governments.
All this anti-Yankee sentiment persisted into my adult discussions of the Civil War, and I continued the tradition of defeat. The Civil War was about states’ rights, far more than it was about slavery. Most southerners didn’t even OWN slaves, and many who did were right kind to them. Yankees always think they are so moral and pure, but even they didn’t like free blacks and took drastic measures to ensure that freedom and liberty to the emancipated did not equate into white men’s jobs. And so it was until I began my genealogical journey.
In census documents, deeds and wills, slavery became slaves–people that my people owned, like the trees they sold for lumber and the hogs they raised to butcher. My people participated in one of history’s slave cultures, using the commodity of bonded labor to produce commodities like tobacco to be sold in a global economy. To ignore the stories of slaves, even if they are only names found in documents, is to ignore black pioneering in the United States. What is contained in my family’s papers, documents and stories will be shared whenever and wherever possible.
For me, it is time to drop the cloak of defeat, and be a true Virginian, honoring all the people who contributed to the development and promise of that state, and to all of these United States.
4 thoughts on “The Cloak of Defeat: Friday’s Facing The War”
I am an Ohioian, as you I honor my maternal great grandfather, a Virginian, a Confederate soldier of the 54th Virginia, a non slave holding family who arrived in Muskingum County, Ohio 1865-1870. One of three known Confederates buried here in Yankee land. He lay buried buried along with his wife also a Virginian for 86 years in an umarked grave. In 1998 I contacted the Vet Admin and received a bronze marker for him. We had a special ceremony with 125 attending with many in period clothing and a Confederate 21 gun salute. We started with Battle Hymn of the Republic (after all we were victorius). Then Carry me back to Old Virginny. My uncle spread soil from the state of Virginia over the graves when a fellow stepped from the crowd and sang Dixie. We ended with God Bless America. It was one of the proudest moments of my life and I consider it a “Badge of Life” for me
I am moved by all the stories being recounted as we confront our nation’s civil war sesquicentennial. Thank you for sharing.
Your essay is beautifully and powerfully written. We all had a role and still have a role in realizing the “American dream” for everyone.
Thank you. I appreciate your stopping by, and commenting.