Serendipity Surrounds a Secret
My mother’s family was a well-to-do farming clan – the Minors of Greene County. Cattle and stock dealers for generations, the family groups had accumulated hundreds of acres of hilly land in southwestern Pennsylvania by the turn of the twentieth century when the bituminous Pittsburgh coal vein prompted a speculative race. Around 1905 the rights to that black gold were sold, by some accounts for up to $600 per acre, and the Francis Marion Minor family was suddenly land AND cash rich. In spite of the opportunities afforded the prosperous, my great-grandfather, Robert Minor, suffered from horrible headaches and melancholy, traveling throughout his life from health resort to health resort seeking relief . I haven’t been able to pinpoint a reason for his brooding. Some secret lurks within family lore. It hangs over other stories like the fog lingering over the Susquehanna River even as the rest of the Wyoming Valley clears to reveal its broad plain, mountain ridges and blue dome sky.
Last week I stepped away from the shroud to gain perspective, re-searching the family patriarch in case some new record or paper had been digitalized.
John P. Minor + cattle
Among the google-returned items was a newspaper article from 1908. My great-great-great-grandfather Minor died in 1874. But. . . . If an article catches my interest, I read first and judge relevance later. Suddenly this unexpected detail poked through the family fog:
- A quick review of the family register confirmed that THIS John P. Minor was the eldest brother of my great-grandfather, Robert Minor. John Minor had married Elizabeth Garard, and they had one child, Ira, who died December 12, 1908.
- A further newspaper search at the Library of Congress Chronicling America yielded multiple accounts of the bank’s failure in 1906 – and of this young man’s suicide. Mr. Rinehart was convicted in January of 1909 for stealing funds from the bank and sentenced to 15 years in prison.
- The postcards which document my great-grandfather’s descent into headaches and melancholy were postmarked 1910.
- After rereading my Minor documents of that era, I am not convinced that the fortune mentioned in the article was that of John P. Minor alone, but perhaps that of the entire FM Minor clan. Even so, the $500,000 dollars would have been the equivalent of $12,000,000 dollars in 2009. Losing half of that sum would have resulted in the family being worth “only” $6 million dollars, with the economic clout of someone with $131 million dollars in 2009. *¹ Split among four families, that is still a grand fortune, by my book.
Did the Minor family have a predisposition to brooding, melancholy, headaches, and other “nervous ailments” and was my great-grandfather’s depression caused by this bank failure or by the family crisis that came in its wake? Why did Robert Minor continue to suffer? And what ever happened to all of that money?
Perhaps I will never really know the true nature of the secret, or be privy to the knowledge that hurt this family so deeply. This genealogical serendipity surrounds my secret, however, helping to define its edges and contain its outline. At the very least, I know that there really was a family fortune, that there really was family tragedy and that at least some members of the family – like Robert Minor – had difficulty coping.
The secret is by my side now, not lurking in a corner driving me mad.
*¹ The website Measuring Worth is extremely helpful in calculating the relative worth of the U. S. Dollar, from 1774- the present.
11 thoughts on “Serendipity Surrounds a Secret: Madness Monday”
Pingback: Family Secrets Lurking 1.0 – Amanuensis Monday « d kay s days
It’s possible he had migraines (and there is a genetic component to migraines) and along with the chronic pain, there is often depression–and they didn’t have the meds to help control them back then.
Yes, I have wondered about that possibility. Robert lived until 1943, spending at least some portion of his final years in a psychiatric facility, according to my mother. Was he being treated for migraines, depression, chronic pain at that time? And if so, why would the family hide that? I certainly will be reading my family documents with an eye for more clues!
Thanks for your input!
also, there could have been drug addiction issues if the pain was treated with narcotics. that would be something a family might keep secret. and then there’s the fact that migraines have a history of being misunderstood, with some people believing they were caused by psychological problems.
So interesting! As to why they would hide it – it was a much more private time. People didn’t even mention cancer in public when I was growing up in the 50s and 60’s. I was told relatives had “female” problems. Even today senior members of our family are often reluctant to say anything about their parents or relatives that might be interpreted as negative – including illnesses.
In Victorian times things were even more private. Anything that even suggested mental instability could easily have been considered shameful and hidden.
There was certainly a stronger wall between public and private spaces than exists today! Perhaps my mother can recall more memories of her grandfather as I discuss my new findings. ~Kay
Thank you both, Jill and Susan. You have given me some great insight into these family clues! I hadn’t thought to consider an addiction to pain killers. . . .Thanksgiving should be an interesting family gathering. 🙂
Wow. This is a fascinating series of stories. I hope you keep us updated if you find out more.
I’m glad that you are as intrigued as I am! 🙂 You can be sure that I will update as I can!
You did an awesome job of pulling all the pieces of this story together. It’s interesting how newspaper articles about suicides were much more graphic a hundred years ago than they are today–yet in many ways people were more private back then.
Thanks! Interesting that the story made national headlines but faded into family oblivion. Thanks for stopping by!